Warner v. Calvert & NM Mediation Procedures Act

The New Mexico Court of Appeals has recently issued the first reported decision applying the New Mexico Mediation Procedures Act,  NMSA §§ 44-7B-1 et seq.*  Warner v. Calvert, et al., 2011-NMCA-028, cert. not applied for.  The Court concluded that a non-party participant to a mediation could be admitted as an expert in a subsequent trail, after mediation fell through, although the non-party participant's valuation report could not be admitted .

The Modern Method of Overturning Precedent

In the May 2011 issue of the ABA Journal, Richard Brust comments on the U.S. Supreme Court's emergent "stealth" method of overturning precedent.

2011 a Big Year in NM for ALJs and Hearing Examiners

2011 is shaping up to be quite a year in New Mexico for Administrative Law Judges and Hearing Officials.  The National Association of Administrative Law Judiciary (NAALJ) is having their Annual Conference in Santa Fe from September 18-21, 2011, at the beautiful La Fonda Hotel.  See http://www.naalj.org/conferences. Then, the National Association of Hearing Officials (NAHO) is holding its annual Professional Development Conference in Santa Fe from November 13-16, 2011, also at the La Fonda Hotel.  See http://www.naho.org/.

Wise Tips on Brief (and Opinion!) Writing

In the Fall 2010 issue of the ABA Journal of the Section of Litigation (Vol. 37, No. 1), retired Florida judge Larry A.Klein provides much excellent and insightful advise on brief writing.  As decision makers, we've all been presented with some great briefs and some awful ones and, as Judge Klein notes, it is sometimes even very qualified, well-regarded counsel that make the following mistakes.  Moreover, the tips are so perfectly suited to all legal writing that I have made a number of notes to myself to watch out for in the future.

The "Reasonable Person" -- a Product of Social Mores, Not a Mathematician

Micheal J. De Vinne, lawyer and historian, recently wrote a quite delightful piece tracing the evolution of that ubiquitous legal fiction, the "reasonable person."  See "The Reasonable Person as a Living Fossil," ABA Journal of the Section of Litigation, Vol. 37, No. 1, Fall 2010.  In tracing its evolution, he concludes the reasonably person is never defined by the law but rather left to a panel of peers to define based on the collected mores of the times.

Mediator Strategies, and the Role of Mediator Race/Gender

The Fall issue of ACR’s Conflict Resolution Quarterly had a number of very informative and interesting articles that are well worth summary, comment and praise.  See Vol 28, No. 1.  Of particular interest to me were two empirical studies:

• “Do Mediators Walk Their Talk in Civil Cases?,” by James A. Wall, Jr. and Suzanne Chan-Serafin; and
• “Fairness, Understanding, and Satisfaction:  Impact of Mediator and Participant Race and Gender on Participants’ Perception of Mediation,” by Lorig Charkoudian and Ellen Kabcenell Wayne.

The first study adds a very interesting twist to our understanding of the role played by our “mediator demeanor” or “style.”  The second adds texture to what we know and think we understand about gender and race dynamics, while highlighting some unexpected findings.

(Relatively) Recent and Exciting Arbitration Decisions

In the last few years, the legitimacy and reach of arbitration and arbitration clauses have been considerably expanded by the U.S. Supreme Court.  Three in particular interest me because they related to my own practice emphasis:  14 Penn Plaza, Rent-a-Center, and Stolt-Nielsen.  This blog will discuss their basic holdings and why they are significant in the larger scheme of arbitration.